Table of Contents
April Foolsā Day: A little humor can spell big trouble for college newspapers

The University of Alaska-Fairbanks is planning to construct a new building in the shape of a vagina. Administrators at the University of Wisconsin-Superior are selling drugs out of a new campus meth lab in a scheme to lower tuition rates. Parking authority personnel near Rutgers University will start throwing grenades at drivers who park in the wrong location.
Donāt believe me? Good instinct.
These stories were all part of college newspapersā satirical April Foolsā Day editions āand they all caught the critical attention of school administrators.
College publications annually push the envelope to put out gag editions poking fun at administrators, faculty, fellow students, and themselves. The result is a mixed bag of both clever criticism and jokes that donāt land, but the tradition almost always yields administrators rattling the sabres of censorship.
If the past is any indication, someone, somewhere will soon be holding a copy of their campus newspaperās April Foolsā Day edition ā¦ and not laughing. In fact, they may be filing complaints with the schoolās administration, which could lead to a prolonged investigation. Or they may go storming to their (not so) friendly campus ābias response team.ā
Disturbingly, colleges have indeed launched full-fledged investigations into newspapers following satirical editions, threatening the publications with loss of funding and future oversight by content review boards. Staff members have been subjected to sensitivity training. Editors . Newspapers themselves confiscated.
In the name of being āinclusiveā and polite, too many administrations seem willing to squelch free speech. But satire is a time-honored means of criticizing existing conditions ā and itās a protected one at that on public campuses. (Private institutions that grant students free speech rights have a duty to honor that promise, too.) So even when it misses the mark, ruffles feathers, or upsets, the First Amendment is very clear: Satire is protected by the Constitution.
Just ask someone who helped write it.
Benjamin Franklin famously used satire to anonymously poke fun at the British Empire in London newspapers. (And though he was being serious here, this from Ben seems appropriate: āif all Printers were determinād not to print any thing till they were sure it would offend no body, there would be very little printed.ā)
Franklin is not the only one who, historically, has embraced the power of satire to weigh in on the dayās most important public issues. Take the ancient Roman Juvenal who, bitter and cranky, criticizing Roman society. Or silent film star Charlie Chaplin who in āThe Great Dictator.ā Or, more recently, comedian Melissa McCarthy who White House Press Secretary Sean Spicer on Saturday Night Live.
Satire is a unique and persuasive tool. Itās one that can be particularly useful for criticizing the powerful ā a form of political speech the First Amendment was specifically designed to protect. Colleges should therefore think twice before succumbing to the kneejerk reaction of shutting down this kind of commentary, especially since many are studied on the very same campuses. And while campus news readers may not find every attempt at satire finds its target, freedom of speech means students must have the freedom to try their hand at satirical wit and miss ā or .
If your April Foolsā edition lands your newspaper in trouble, get in touch with ¹ū¶³“«Ć½app¹Ł·½.
Recent Articles
FIREās award-winning Newsdesk covers the free speech news you need to stay informed.

VICTORY! Charges dropped against TN woman cited for using skeletons in Christmas decorations

VICTORY! 9th Circuit rules in favor of professor punished for criticizing college for lowering academic standards

Free speech advocates rally to support ¹ū¶³“«Ć½app¹Ł·½ās federal appeal to defend advocacy in public parks
