Williams College: Student Group Denied Recognition for Pro-Israel Viewpoint
Cases
Williams College
Case Overview
On April 23, 2019, Williams College鈥檚 student government, the College Council, voted to deny Registered Student Organization status to prospective student group Williams Initiative for Israel (WIFI) because of the group鈥檚 pro-Israel viewpoint. Recognition was denied to WIFI even though it had complied with all College Council Requirements, making WIFI the first club in over a decade to be denied recognition. In a statement, Williams President Maud Mandel wrote that she was 鈥渄isappointed鈥 with the group鈥檚 decision and promised that WIFI could operate on campus without recognition from the College Council, but the Council is responsible for distributing student fees to the groups it recognizes. FIREwrote to Mandel on May 15 to warn that a college that commits to freedom of expression must do more when an agent acting on its behalf violates that commitment. In response, Williams notified FIREthat WIFI had been recognized through a 鈥減arallel path鈥 to registered student organization status.