Cornell University: Student Punished for Posting āZionists must dieā on Social Media
Cases
Cornell University
Case Overview
On January 11, 2024, Cornell University announced that a student Maria Lima Valdez āwill be held fully accountable and appropriately sanctionedā for her āheinousā and āhatefulā social media post saying āZionists must die.ā Cornell suspended Valdez and banned her from campus on January 16, pending its disciplinary investigation. However, Cornellās free speech policies explicitly protect offensive or hateful speech, and the university did not show how the post falls into any category of unprotected speech.
FIRE wrote Cornell January 17 calling on the university to refrain from punishing students for passionate and protected political rhetoric on public issues. Cornell failed to respond. On February 17, FIREagain urged Cornell to lift Valdezās suspension because her speech did not pose an immediate danger to campus. Cornell eventually found Valdez not responsible for all disciplinary charges on May 23.