¹ū¶³“«Ć½app¹Ł·½

Table of Contents

Report: Threats to Student Media ā€˜Disturbingly Routineā€™

Journalist holding a microphone and writing in a notebook

Widespread attempts by university administrators to silence student journalists pose a grave threat to those journalists, their publications, and the campus community at large, according to released today by the , the , the , and the . The groups urge colleges and universities to combat these threats by committing to a free press on campus and embracing ā€œhigher educationā€™s traditional commitment to free and independent journalistic voices.ā€

The details both the scope and nature of the threats student journalists and their advisers face, arguing that publicly reported casesā€”including recent high-profile onesā€”appear to ā€œjust be the tip of a much larger iceberg.ā€

ā€œIt has become disturbingly routine for student journalists and their advisers to experience overt hostility that threatens their ability to inform the campus community,ā€ the report concludes. That hostility includes threats against advisers to conduct prior review of news stories and otherwise ā€œcontrol content,ā€ or face termination. Defunding efforts and other financially-based censorship of student publications, as well as denial of student journalistsā€™ access to critical information, are also rampant, the report says.

The report also underscores the important, multi-faceted role student journalism plays in the civic health of college communities. Because financial shortfalls have gutted professional newsrooms, ā€œcollege and university journalists are today asked to bear more responsibility than ever before.ā€

But that role as campus watchdog has made these reporters the target of some college administrators who may have secrets to hide. ā€œObstruction and harassment of campus media frequently signify deeper institutional mismanagement that administrators may seek to downplay or conceal,ā€ the report states. One particularly jarring example is included:

[T]he administration of Californiaā€™s Southwest College mounted a campaign of intimidation and bullying of student journalistsā€”including freezing the newspaperā€™s printing budget, cutting the adviserā€™s salary, and even threatening staff members with arrestā€”as part of an effort to conceal high-level wrongdoing. The administrator responsible for the harassment campaign, Raj Chopra, was forced out of office soon afterward as part of a wide-ranging ā€œpay-to-playā€ corruption scandal encompassing members of the collegeā€™s board of trustees and contractors. The scandal resulted in criminal charges against eighteen individuals, including Chopra, who ended up accepting a guilty plea and serving three yearsā€™ probation.

(FIREpushed back against several of Chopraā€™s other speech-chilling activities in the run-up to his abrupt resignation from Southwestern College in 2010.)

Courts may not provide a ready remedy, either. Legal precedent governing the rights of student newspapers is ā€œunsettlingly disparate,ā€ leaving student journalists and their advisers in ā€œa gray zone of legal uncertainty,ā€ the groups argue.

But while the facts presented are grim, the report recommends three safeguards colleges and universities can commit to providing their student journalists to secure editorial freedom. They include ensuring full editorial control for student publications, that advisors and editors will not face retaliation for editorial policy or content, and that any institutionally published and financed publications clearly state ā€œthat the opinions there expressed are not necessarily those of the college, university, or student body.ā€

ā€œUltimately,ā€ the report concludes, ā€œensuring a campus environment conducive to substantive journalistic coverage requires a significant cultural readjustment that begins with those at the topmost levels of higher education.ā€

You can find out how to spot censorship and combat it on our Student Press resources page. If youā€™ve been censored on your campus, weā€™re here to help: Contact FIREand submit your case today.

Recent Articles

FIREā€™s award-winning Newsdesk covers the free speech news you need to stay informed.

Share